Sherri Malarik’s Children Took Opposite Sides at Their Mother’s Murder Trial

Prathamesh Kabra
15 Min Read

When Jeff Leake found the family’s red minivan, he opened an unlocked door and reached for his sister-in-law. Sherri Malarik was down on the passenger-side floor, and he called her name and shook her arm. She did not move. It was about eight in the morning on September 22, 2001, in a supermarket parking lot outside Pensacola, less than three miles from her home.

The night before, Sherri had been supervising a sleepover for her children and their cousins. She was 34, a Navy air traffic controller, and someone had shot her twice in the head. Almost nineteen years passed before investigators arrested her husband, Gregory. By the time his second murder trial ended in an acquittal in October 2023, two children from that sleepover had testified on opposing sides.

Her son Jacob believed his stepfather had killed her. Her youngest daughter, Tera, believed her father was innocent. They remembered very different childhoods.

Sherri built her adult life around the Navy and a rapidly expanding family. She was an Air Traffic Controller 1st Class and an instructor at the Naval Aviation Technical Training Center in Pensacola. At home, Jacob remembered a mother who loved music, dancing, and parenting, and who kept a busy household organized.

Sherri Malarik in her Navy dress uniform.
Sherri Malarik, a Navy air traffic controller, in an undated service portrait. Credit: Didi Scott, via PEOPLE.

She and Greg met while stationed in Bermuda in the early 1990s. Each brought children into the relationship, and they had three more together. Jacob’s earliest memories of Greg include being picked up from day care for fishing trips and motorcycle rides. By 2001, five children lived in the household, and the family’s connections extended to the cousins who came over to play.

Military service complicated keeping everyone together. According to relatives interviewed for Dateline, Sherri accepted a yearlong assignment in Greece so the family could remain settled afterward rather than move again. While she was away, a Navy employee named Jennifer Spohn began babysitting. In Jacob’s recollection, her visits gradually stretched beyond the hours Greg needed someone to watch the children.

Jacob later described seeing Greg and Spohn together on the living room floor with wine, behaving intimately. His account of home life also included frightening punishments, among them being made to eat dried cayenne peppers. He said Greg’s behavior was more restrained when Sherri was there. Greg denied abusing the children. The affair itself would eventually become central to the murder prosecution.

Sherri Malarik smiles at two of her children in costumes.
Sherri Malarik with two of her children. Photograph courtesy of the family, via NBC News.

On Friday, September 21, Sherri and Greg had extra children in the house because her sister Tina and Tina’s husband, Jeff, were attending a military ball. The cousins had pizza and video games. Jacob, eleven, remembered his mother briefly leaving them to speak to Greg outside. In a later interview, he recalled her saying, “Hey, I’m going to go outside to talk to your dad.”

What happened around that departure became the subject of repeated interviews. Lisa Leake, one of the cousins, told investigators she heard a pop like a firecracker after Sherri went outside, then saw Greg come in, shower, and change clothes. Greg told police that Sherri had announced a quick trip to the store. When she had not come home by about eleven, he began calling relatives and police.

Spohn also visited that evening. She and Greg explained that she had borrowed a lawn mower and had come to return it around nine. Detective Buddy Nesmith later recalled that Greg introduced her name himself during questioning. Nesmith already knew about the affair. He marked down the time of her visit, a detail that would remain in the case long after the first interviews ended.

In the van Jeff found the next morning, blood had spattered a children’s Bible. Nesmith described Sherri’s body as forced down into the floorboard, apparently to conceal it, but there was no blood on the pavement. He suspected she had been shot elsewhere and driven to the parking lot.

A children's Bible on the gray floor of Sherri Malarik's minivan in a September 2001 evidence photograph.
A children’s Bible on the floor of Sherri Malarik’s minivan, photographed during the September 2001 investigation. Credit: Office of the State Attorney, First Judicial Circuit of Florida, via PEOPLE.

At the house, another discovery troubled Nesmith. Sherri’s purse, credit cards, and checkbook were in a bedroom drawer. Greg’s explanation that she had gone shopping now meant she had left those things behind.

The wounds established how violently she died. At trial, the prosecution described medical evidence of two shots to the head, with a complete .25-caliber bullet recovered inside her head and fragments from another shot found in her head and the van’s roof lining. The state reconstructed the shooting with Sherri sitting in the front passenger seat before her body was pushed down into the footwell. Where the gunman stood and how the bullets traveled would become contested parts of the case.

Investigators found reasons to suspect Greg, but the evidence did not produce an immediate arrest. An arrest report later made public described positive gunshot-residue swabs from his hands and gunpowder in a trouser pocket. The murder weapon was never recovered. Greg denied owning or having access to a .25-caliber handgun, while investigators said witnesses contradicted him. Spohn maintained that her visit was to return the mower.

Sherri Malarik's purse inside a bedroom drawer in a Dateline image of the evidence.
Investigators found Sherri Malarik’s purse in a bedroom drawer during the investigation. Credit: Dateline, via PEOPLE.

The children continued growing up while those questions remained open. Jacob described a household in which discussion of his mother was constrained, and remembered Greg warning them to keep family business within the family. In an earlier letter he later shared with Court TV, Jacob wrote to Sherri, “It’s been 19 years since I’ve been able to see your face or hear your voice.”

Tera was a toddler when Sherri died. In an interview released on Talking Dateline, she described an explanation she carried into childhood. Because her mother served in the military, she imagined Sherri was away on a secret mission. Until about eleven, she thought that when the mission ended, her mother would come home.

Sherri Malarik holds her young daughter Tera, who is wearing a red dress.
Sherri Malarik with her daughter Tera. Photograph courtesy of the family, via NBC News.

Tera remembered a protective father who shared her love of music and old movies. At fifteen, a cousin’s Facebook message told her he was suspected of killing Sherri. She confronted him, and he denied it. She had not known about the suspicion until then.

Jacob tried to keep his distance from Greg, but his younger siblings still lived with him. When Jacob married in 2015, he sent his stepfather an invitation. He later told Dateline he wanted the younger children at his wedding and believed they couldn’t attend without Greg.

The investigation eventually returned to the sleepover. NCIS reviewed old interviews and telephone records to determine whether Greg could have driven to Winn-Dixie and back that evening. On March 6, 2020, agents and sheriff’s investigators arrested him at home. He was then a civilian employee at the same naval training center where Sherri had worked. Authorities publicly spoke of resolution. An NCIS official said he hoped the arrest would bring “peace and closure to Ms. Malarik’s loved ones.”

Gregory Malarik in a booking photograph published in 2020.
Gregory Malarik in a booking photograph published in 2020. A jury acquitted him of Sherri Malarik’s murder in October 2023. Credit: Escambia County Sheriff’s Office, via Navy Times.

After the arrest, Spohn gave investigators an account that went far beyond returning a lawn mower. She received immunity and became the prosecution’s crucial witness. She alleged that Greg had once suggested killing Sherri would be easier than going through a third divorce.

In her testimony, Spohn said Greg directed her to meet him at Winn-Dixie. She picked him up beside the van, drove him home, and helped make her appearance at the house look like an ordinary visit. She also described throwing items from bags he gave her, including a gun, off a bridge. She said she followed his instructions. She had not witnessed the shooting.

She also testified about a conversation she said they had years after Sherri’s death. According to Spohn, Greg told her he had fired once, realized he could not undo it, and shot Sherri again. Greg denied killing his wife, and his lawyer challenged both Spohn’s story and the questioning that produced it.

Jennifer Spohn testifies at Gregory Malarik's October 2023 trial.
Jennifer Spohn testifies during Gregory Malarik’s October 2023 trial. The jury acquitted Malarik. Image: Court TV.

At the first trial, Jacob tried not to look at Greg while testifying, he later told Court TV. Their eyes met on his second day of questioning. The jury deadlocked in June 2022. When the case returned to court in October 2023, Jacob testified for the prosecution again. Tera testified for the defense. The children who once shared the same home were now helping opposing lawyers explain what happened there.

Defense attorney Christopher Crawford focused on a particularly damaging mistake. In his closing argument, he said investigators had dismantled the van searching for a projectile that was already in evidence under an incorrect label. When they recognized what they had during the first trial, they conducted further testing, and an expert’s opinion on the bullets’ trajectories changed. Crawford asked jurors to distrust a reconstruction built on evidence whose handling he had spent the trial challenging.

He also attacked the process that led Spohn to change her account. Investigators had presented her with a hypothetical version of events before she implicated Greg. The defense suggested that she could have killed Sherri herself and benefited from an agreement that protected her from prosecution. Spohn denied killing Sherri.

Prosecutor Amy Shea acknowledged forensic mistakes in her closing argument. She said the forensics pointed neither toward Greg nor away from him, and argued that those problems did not negate Spohn’s information. The state relied on the affair, the children’s recollections, telephone records, and the account of the woman who said she drove him home.

The M.C. Blanchard Judicial Building in Pensacola, photographed in December 2010.
The M.C. Blanchard Judicial Building in Pensacola in December 2010. Photograph: Georgia Guercio / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

On October 13, after eight hours and twenty-six minutes of deliberations, the jury found Greg not guilty of first-degree murder. The verdict ended the state’s case against him without establishing who killed Sherri.

Afterward, Tera told the Pensacola News Journal, “It would suck to lose the only parent I have left.”

By the time Dateline interviewed the family for its February 2024 broadcast, Tera was preparing for the birth of her first child. She said she wanted Sherri at her graduation and wanted her there as she became a mother herself. She also wanted Jacob to meet the baby.

Jacob and Tera Malarik embrace at Tera's graduation.
Jacob and Tera Malarik at Tera’s graduation, in a family photograph published by NBC News. Photograph courtesy of the family.

Jacob told Dateline he had sent Tera a birthday text. He explained what he wanted her to understand. “I haven’t written you off. I’m just not ready yet.”

In her own interview, Tera left the invitation open. “I’m ready whenever he is.”

For more stories of long investigations, read about the search for Dee Anne Warner, whose remains were found inside a sealed tank, or the student film that helped reopen Janet Chandler’s murder case.

Image rights notice: If you are a copyright holder and have concerns about an image used in this article, please get in touch with us. We will review your request and remove the image where appropriate.

Share This Article
Prathamesh is a curious mind who dives deep into mysteries, the bizarre and the unexplained. He’s always chasing the weirdest true stories he can find.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *