On February 6, 1989, Mari Konno’s father opened his front door to leave for work and found a cardboard box in the way. His four-year-old daughter had been missing for nearly six months. At first, he thought a neighborhood child had left something outside.
Inside were ashes, bones and teeth, along with photographs of Mari’s clothing. He decided that his wife must not see the contents and called the police. A message included their daughter’s name and instructed the authorities to examine the remains.
The man who left the box, Tsutomu Miyazaki, followed the coverage of its discovery. When the initial examination raised doubts about whether the remains belonged to Mari, he wrote to correct the impression. He saw her mother expressing renewed hope on television and wanted her to understand that her daughter was dead.
Mari disappeared from Iruma, in Saitama Prefecture, on August 22, 1988. She went out to play that afternoon and failed to come home. Her mother reported her missing shortly after six. Her father, occupied with work in Tokyo, missed the last train and stayed overnight at an inn. He did not learn what happened until the police contacted him at his company the following morning.
He began looking in places he knew through his daughter. He revisited their outings and traveled along the Seibu railway, getting off at one station after another to search. He also walked through the mountains, wondering whether she might have fallen into water somewhere. He told journalist Toshiyuki Kobayashi that he spent 80 days searching.
“I was prepared to spend five or ten years looking for my daughter,” he said, in Kobayashi’s account of their interview.
Police initially prepared for a ransom demand, placing officers inside the family home and installing recording equipment. None came. Miyazaki killed Mari on the day she disappeared. He approached her near a pedestrian bridge, offered to take her somewhere cool and drove her into the wooded hills around Itsukaichi, where he strangled her. He subsequently filmed her body.
Six weeks later, seven-year-old Masami Yoshizawa disappeared from nearby Hanno. Miyazaki approached her on October 3, pretending to need directions, and persuaded her to enter his car. He took her into the same general area of woodland and killed her. Both families continued searching without knowing that their daughters were dead.
The discovery that changed the investigation came in December. Four-year-old Erika Namba vanished from Kawagoe on December 9. Six days later, police found her body in woodland at Naguri. Miyazaki photographed her before strangling her and left her bound. A postcard delivered to her family carried a sequence of words assembled from copied print, beginning with Erika’s name and ending with death. Investigators now had a murdered child and two other young girls still missing in the same part of Saitama.
Miyazaki’s contact with the families continued after the killings. The box at Mari’s door was followed by a confession sent to the Asahi Shimbun and her parents. He signed it “Yuko Imada,” presenting himself under a woman’s name. The letter insisted that he alone was responsible and that the bones really were Mari’s.
His response to the uncertainty over the remains was particularly deliberate. A dental examiner initially suggested that the teeth probably did not belong to Mari, then reconsidered. Miyazaki used the first announcement as the reason for writing. As journalist Charles T. Whipple documented in his early account of the investigation, the killer claimed that he was preventing her mother from continuing to hope in vain.
Police formally identified the remains on March 1. Mari’s funeral took place ten days later, and another letter arrived that day. It thanked the family for arranging the funeral. Under the same invented identity, Miyazaki also claimed that his own child’s remains were being buried with Mari’s. He continued corresponding with people who still had no idea who he was.
Three months after the funeral, he abducted another child.
Five-year-old Ayako Nomoto disappeared on June 6 from Tokyo’s Koto ward, farther from the earlier abductions. Miyazaki approached her with his camera and asked to photograph her. He took her into his car and strangled her in a nearby parking area. This time, he brought the body home.
He kept Ayako’s remains in his room, made recordings and dismembered the body two days after the murder. He disposed of remains in separate locations. On June 11, a body was discovered behind a toilet building in a cemetery in Hanno. Examiners identified Ayako through several features, including her blood type and a mark below her knee. Her family had reported her missing only five days earlier.
The crimes included sexual abuse of the children’s bodies and the production of recordings that Miyazaki kept for himself. His subsequent statements added allegations of cannibalism. Agence France-Presse reported that he confessed to consuming some remains of two victims. The Associated Press, more cautiously, attributed reports of cannibalism and drinking a victim’s blood to Japanese newspapers. Those claims circulated alongside the documented murders, mutilation and recordings, although the Supreme Court’s published judgment did not make a separate finding of cannibalism.
Miyazaki was caught on July 23, 1989, after approaching two sisters in Hachioji. He separated the younger child, who was six, from her older sister and began sexually exploiting and photographing her. The older girl fetched their father, who confronted Miyazaki and knocked him down. Miyazaki escaped, then returned to his car, where police arrested him. The younger child survived.
The arrest did not immediately resolve the murders. Detectives were checking men suspected of sexual offenses against children, and Miyazaki was among them. During questioning in August, he mentioned visiting the Ariake tennis grounds near the area where Ayako disappeared. A detective pursued the connection. Miyazaki began admitting what he had done and guided police to remains.
A search of his room produced nearly 6,000 videotapes. Seventy-four investigators, using 50 video players, spent two weeks examining the collection. They found footage of Mari’s body and then footage of Ayako. These were recordings made by the man they held, of children whose families had searched for them.
The Los Angeles Times reported that footage of Mari’s body appeared among recorded television news reports about the killings.
Yet the room’s commercial tapes and comics soon attracted attention of their own. Miyazaki’s collection became a widely circulated explanation for the murders, and his identity as an obsessive fan helped attach the label “otaku” to the case. Reporters and television crews went looking for other enthusiasts at manga conventions and specialist shops.
In her study of the ensuing panic, scholar Sharon Kinsella documented how amateur manga culture became associated with dangerous, psychologically disturbed young men. Commentators assembled explanations from Miyazaki’s interests, his family relationships and his apparent isolation. His room offered a recognizable image to put beside the crimes, but the presence of comics and animation did not establish why he murdered children. kinsellaresearch.com
His family background also became public material. Born in 1962, Miyazaki grew up in a household that published a local newspaper, the Akikawa Shimbun. He had a congenital forearm disability that prevented him from turning his palms upward normally. His grandfather, who took a substantial role in his upbringing, died shortly before the killings began.
These circumstances entered attempts to explain his behavior, but they did not provide a single agreed explanation. His family’s life disintegrated after his arrest. The newspaper ceased publication, and his parents left the area. His father died by suicide in November 1994, while the trial was still underway.
By then, the central courtroom dispute concerned Miyazaki’s responsibility for acts supported by confessions and physical evidence. When proceedings opened in March 1990, he spoke as though the crimes belonged to a different reality.
“I felt as though I was in a dream I couldn’t wake from,” he said, in Kobayashi’s recollection of attending the trial. He also spoke of a “rat man” appearing and leaving him confused. Kobayashi watched him turn a pencil in his fingers and sometimes appear to doze during proceedings.
Psychiatric assessments produced conflicting conclusions. One found a personality disorder but concluded that Miyazaki retained the ability to understand right and wrong and act accordingly. Others identified dissociative symptoms or schizophrenia and considered his responsibility diminished. The disagreement concerned both his condition and what it meant for his ability to control his conduct when he committed the crimes. It could not be settled simply by calling his statements bizarre.
The Tokyo District Court accepted the finding that he was criminally responsible and sentenced him to death on April 14, 1997. The proceedings had lasted seven years. Appeals continued through the Tokyo High Court and finally reached the Supreme Court, which upheld the sentence on January 17, 2006.
The Supreme Court’s judgment emphasized his increasing planning as the crimes continued. It identified sexual gratification and his desire to possess unusual recordings of his own as principal motives. It also considered what he did after killing the girls, including abusing and filming bodies and sending remains and statements to their families.
The judges acknowledged circumstances offered in mitigation, including his disability, lack of previous convictions and initial admissions. His mother had sent a total of eight million yen to the bereaved families. They nevertheless concluded that the death sentence should stand.
Miyazaki continued writing from prison. Before the Supreme Court ruling, he sent Kyodo News a letter maintaining his innocence and saying that he thought he “did a good thing.” In a book published after the ruling, he interpreted the attention surrounding it as evidence “that I am popular.”
A clinical psychologist who met him eight times in January 2006 offered a different view of those statements. Hirokazu Hasegawa said he could not determine Miyazaki’s mental competence at the time of the murders, but believed his grasp of reality was severely impaired when they met. Kyodo’s reporting on those interviews and letters preserved both the absence of remorse and the continuing uncertainty about his mental condition.
That uncertainty remained when his lawyer asked the justice minister not to execute him in May 2008. The International Federation for Human Rights and Japan’s Center for Prisoners’ Rights reported that Miyazaki received psychiatric treatment in detention for more than a decade. Their joint statement said neither his family nor his lawyers received advance notice of his execution.
On June 17, 2008, Miyazaki was hanged at the Tokyo Detention House. He was 45. Almost twenty years had passed since Mari went out to play.
Back in March 1989, before anyone knew the killer’s name, Masami’s mother told Kobayashi that she slept in her clothes so she could leave immediately if information arrived. She still hoped her daughter’s disappearance was unrelated to the other cases.
She also remembered an outing with Masami, before her own child vanished. They saw one of the posters asking for help finding Mari. Masami stopped to consider the missing girl.
“That poor child,” she told her mother.